At Goldstar, we rely on likes as an event recommendation signal. As such, it has significant value for the business.
The feature, originally called Starring, evolved out of two other features — email alerts and bookmarks. We simplified it into a widget we could use throughout the site as a signal of social interest that would personalize members' experiences and send them alerts when we got new tickets.
Starring was a great success when we rolled it out. But over time, it became clear it hid baggage that was preventing it from reaching its potential.
This is where UX research helped us recognize that — long story short — the feature wasn't mapping to users' mental models as easily as we'd have liked. After researching the issue, it was clear that we had to find a way to reshape the feature into something more universal.
We ran a number of studies and user interviews to gather feedback. What users told us was crystal clear: while some of them were able to deduce the feature's intent, most just didn't get it.
If there's a lesson here it's that 1) our audiences are always evolving, and a feature designed two years ago might not resonate today, and 2) we almost always carry institutional biases into our design processes.
I think what made this project so interesting/insidious is how small those biases were, but they occured in just the right phase of development to push us off course, and in a way that we wouldn't feel for two years.
The research was distilled into a user story about our Karen persona wanting to personalize her experience so she wouldn't miss out on great events.
Fear of missing out is a very strong, recurring theme with our engaged members.
Fixing a feature like starring raises two questions: what are we going to replace it with, and how are we going to execute the change?
Our first inclination was to add more explanation to support starring, but as we let that idea steep — separate research was revealing a lot about about how deeply users were engaged with us — we realized there were hard limits on what we could teach the average member.
So we decided that we should go all in with the feature users kept mentioning during our interviews and tests: likes. The simple, clickable heart. It's obvious in hindsight, but it was difficult to completely reset our thinking about the feature could be.
Starring was everywhere on the site, and changing it was going to be a serious undertaking — not to mention one that was never going to be prioritized on the roadmap. We'd have to figure out a way to ninja the changes in-between other projects.
With one of our senior designers, I planned out a strategy that broke the migration into meaningful, achievable chunks. It was a wholly imperfect strategy, and it took some cajoling on my part, but it was the clearest path to getting the work done.
We attacked onboarding first, since it was effectively isolated from the rest of the site, and adding likes there made a lot of sense as a first step.
While preparing this work, I noticed another bug that was keeping more members out of onboarding. Working with one of our engineers, we identified where the flow was falling down, and we crafted a simple solution that got more new members into onboarding, but also existing members who've never been onboarded.
I tracked onboarding activity through the next few days to make sure it was working, and watched for any customer service feedback. After a few days, we deployed a few small enhancements to the copy and behavior of onboarding, to address some edge cases.
As a result of directing more members into onboarding, we saw a 10x increase in onboarding sessions and a 3x increase in likes. In addition, the new, simpler likes generated 25% more clicks per user.
Likes have been rolled out to everyone, and are performing as well as the old starring feature. We're currently planning experiments to hopefully boost engagement further.
It's still early days, but we're extremely happy with the outcome. Our overall engagement is higher with room to grow, and the mental model maps more closely with users' expectations, which should reduce friction going forward.